Whisky Advocate 93 points - TOP 20 WHISKIES OF 2018 #4 - After many limited releases, we finally have a permanent age-statement expression of Port Charlotte, with a satisfying number of years under its belt. Distilled from Scottish-grown barley, it is matured predominantly in first-fill American oak casks, along with second-fill American and second-fill French wine casks. It is peated to 40ppm, in line with other Islay heavy-hitters, but the peat is never a blunt instrument, retaining sufficient restraint to allow other characteristics-maritime notes, the sweetness of caramel, coconut, and orchard fruits-to shine through. -Gavin D Smith.December/2018